Trip Overview  |  Cities & States - The Itinerary  |  The Travelers  |  Trip Scorecard  |  Best & Worst  |  Daily Journal  |  The Beads
People We've Met  |  Pie We've Eaten  |  Places Visited  |  Planning  |  Road Food  |  Photo Gallery  |  Rules of the Road  |  Our Book  |  Home

Pie We've Eaten -- Complete List

Bill and Barbara Windsor's trip 'Round America covered 50 states and over 2,500 towns.
The Windsors are writing a book about the experience, and these are the pies (and other desserts) they've eaten.

The Best Pie in America  |  Special Pie Places  |  The Great Pie Adventure  |  Unusual Pies  | 
The Worst Pie in America  |  Methodology  |  Complete List of Pies and Rankings

A complete list of the pies eaten and the ratings are below:

Number Pie Place Rating Day
         
1 Blackberry Cobbler Madison Gift Mart & Cafe -- Madison, GA 87 1
2 White Chocolate Coconut Cream Pie The Shrimp Factory -- Savannah, GA 88 1
3 Peach Cobbler Lady & Sons -- Savannah, GA 70 2
4 Banana Pudding Lady & Sons -- Savannah, GA 69 2
5 Chocolate Bomb Cake Villa Parma -- Jensen Beach, FL 80 4
6 Key Lime Pie Harry and the Natives -- Hobe Sound, FL 96 5
7 Fortune Cookies Sum Yum Gai -- Miami Beach, FL 50 5
8 Chocolate Milk Shake Ghirardelli -- Miami, FL 60 6
9 Frozen Key Lime Pie Mrs. Mac's Kitchen -- Key Largo, FL 89 7
10 Key Lime Pie-on-a-Stick Key West Candy Company -- Key West, FL 83 8
11 Banana Heaven Blue Heaven -- Key West, FL 95 8
12 Key Lime Cookie and Slushie Key Lime Heaven -- Key West, FL 60 8
13 Key Lime Pie The Crak'd Conch -- Key Largo, FL 85 9
14 Cocha Mocha Pie The Treasure Ship -- Panama City, FL 88 11
15 Pecan Pie Fairmont Hotel -- New Orleans, LA 60 12
16 Beignets Fairmont Hotel -- New Orleans, LA 78 13
17 Chocolate Pecan Pie The Duson Cafe -- El Campo, TX 83 14
18 Mango Snow Cone Freddy's Fast Lube -- Escobares, TX 92 16
19 Dessert Nachos Starlight Theatre -- Terlingua, TX 65 18
20 Apple Pie No Whiner Diner -- Carlsbad, NM 70 19
21 Alien Pancakes Crash Down Diner -- Roswell, NM 80 20
22 Apple Walnut Raisin Pie Pie-O-Neer Cafe -- Pietown, NM 82 20
23 Peach Pie Pie-O-Neer Cafe -- Pietown, NM 81 20
24 Rhubarb Pie Dot's Diner -- Bisbee, AZ 91 21
25 Mud Pie Little Anthony's Diner -- Tucson, AZ 68 23
26 Date Pie Dateland Restaurant -- Dateland, AZ 68 24
27 Date Shake Dateland Restaurant -- Dateland, AZ 75 24
28 Ice Cream Belmont Park -- Mission Beach, CA 60 25
29 Smoothie Surf Dog's Java Hut -- Encinitas, CA 68 26
30 Pralines N Cream Ice Cream Baskin Robbins -- Rancho Palos Verdes, CA 75 26
31 Banana Cream Pie Hof's Hut -- Long Beach, CA 91 27
32 Fortune Cookies China Garden Restaurant -- Needles, CA 49 29
33 Butterfinger Shake Mr. D'z Diner -- Kingman, AZ 51 30
34 Coconut Cream Pie Pine Tree Restaurant -- Williams, AZ 86 31
35 Blueberry Apple Peach Pie Pine Tree Restaurant -- Williams, AZ 87 31
36 Elvis Pie Pine Tree Restaurant -- Williams, AZ 85 31
37 Chocolate Dipped Cherry Pie Pine Tree Restaurant -- Williams, AZ 84 31
38 Banana Split Black Cow Cafe -- Sedona, AZ 76 32
39 Caramel Apple Raisin Pie Plaza Restaurant -- Santa Fe, NM 94 35
40 Snow Cone Ali's Snow Cone Stand -- Canute, OK 62 38
41 Peach Cobbler Rock Cafe -- Stroud, OK 89 39
42 Toll House Pie Click's Steakhouse -- Pawnee, OK 86 40
43 Grape Pie Rosati's Winery -- Rosati, MO 66 41
44 Caramel Concrete Ted Drewes Frozen Custard -- St. Louis, MO 70 42
45 Apple Dumpling Blues City Cafe -- Memphis, TN 93 43
46 Fudge Pie Cottage Restaurant -- Memphis, TN 78 44
47 Nana Puddin Cottage Restaurant -- Memphis, TN 77 44
48 Coconut Cream Pie Bozzie Jane's Kitchen -- Atlanta, GA 70 46
49 Apple Pie Bozzie Jane's Kitchen -- Atlanta, GA 75 50
50 Pecan Pie The Country Bake Shop -- near Helen, GA 87 57
51 Apple Fritters Applewood Grill -- Pigeon Forge, TN 85 58
52 Apple Cobbler Applewood Grill -- Pigeon Forge, TN 80 58
53 Butterscotch Pie Rogers Restaurant -- Lexington, KY 92 59
54 Lemon Pie Dining Room at Shaker Village -- Pleasant Hill, KY 82 59
55 Buttermilk Pie Mark's Feed Store -- Shelbyville, KY 87 59
56 Very Berry Pie The Stockyards -- Greenup, IL 79 61
57 Coconut Cream Pie Blue Springs Cafe -- Highland, IL 88 61
58 Lemon Meringue Pie Blue Springs Cafe -- Highland, IL 87 61
59 Banana Meringue Pie Blue Springs Cafe -- Highland, IL 84 61
60 Chocolate Meringue Pie Blue Springs Cafe -- Highland, IL 70 61
61 Raspberry Pie Blue Springs Cafe -- Highland, IL 76 61
62 Apple Pie Blue Springs Cafe -- Highland, IL 75 61
63 Raspberry Pie Wes' Restaurant -- Oskaloosa, IA 86 63
64 Coconut Cream Pie Wes' Restaurant -- Oskaloosa, IA 86 63
65 Blueberry Pie Northside Cafe -- Winterset, IA 55 63
66 Strawberry Rhubarb Pie Granny's Kitchen -- Great Bend, KS 86 65
67 Chocolate Malt Economy Drug Store -- Ely, NV 70 68
68 Peach Cobbler Marriott Suites -- Las Vegas, NV 60 70
69 Coconut Cream Pie Baker's Square -- Buellton, CA 84 72
70 Berry Pie Baker's Square -- Buellton, CA 80 72
71 Apple Pie Square Olsen's Danish Bakery -- Solvang, CA 87 73
72 Olallieberry Pie Linn's Bakery & Eatery -- San Luis Obispo, CA 91 73
73 Glazed Doughnuts Krispy Kreme -- San Francisco, CA 80 76
74 Chocolate Dippin Dots Santa Cruz Boardwalk -- Santa Cruz, CA 58 76
75 White Peach Blackberry Pie Buckeye Roadhouse -- Mill Valley, CA 82 80
76 S'more Pie Buckeye Roadhouse -- Mill Valley, CA 82 80
77 Cherry Pie Mel's Drive-In -- San Francisco, CA 81 82
78 Oreo Overload Ice Cream Pie Cold Stone Creamery -- Sausalito, CA 80 84
79 Cherries and Watermelon It Must be Magic! -- San Francisco, CA 70 85
80 Cheddar Cheese Fudge CranBerry Sweets -- Bandon, OR 75 90
81 Apple Raisin Spice Cake The Pancake Mill -- Coos Bay, OR 69 90
82 Fortune Cookies Lee's Restaurant -- Lincoln City, OR 50 90
83 Marionberry Pie Otis Cafe -- Otis, OR 91 91
84 Caramel Butter Pecan Ice Cream Tillamook Cheese Factory -- Tillamook, OR 84 91
85 Cherry Pie Port Townsend Pie Co. -- Port Townsend, WA 88 93
86 Apple Crisp Doubletree Hotel -- SeaTac, WA 76 94
87 Cherry Pie Gwennie's Restaurant -- Anchorage, AK 64 95
88 Apple Pie Gwennie's Restaurant -- Anchorage, AK 64 95
89 Blueberry Pie Gwennie's Restaurant -- Anchorage, AK 64 95
90 Apple Dumpling Gwennie's Restaurant -- Anchorage, AK 64 95
91 Cherry Pie Saturday Market -- Anchorage, AK 80 96
92 Apple with Caramel Sauce Saturday Market -- Anchorage, AK 76 96
93 Champagne Cake Alaska Airlines -- Anchorage, AK 55 97
94 Triple Coconut Cream Pie Dahlia's Bakery -- Seattle, WA 89 99
95 Bing Cherry Chocolate Pie Dahlia's Bakery -- Seattle, WA 85 99
96 Blueberry Brown Sugar Pie Dahlia's Bakery -- Seattle, WA 85 99
97 Raspberry Pie Dutch Mother's Restaurant -- Lynden, WA 97 100
98 Caramel Apple Pie Dutch Mother's Restaurant -- Lynden, WA 86 100
99 Bumbleberry Pie Dutch Mother's Restaurant -- Lynden, WA 90 100
100 Cherry Pie Twede's (Twin Peaks) Cafe -- North Bend, WA 85 101
101 Aplets and Cotlets Candy Aplets and Cotlets Factory -- Cashmere, WA 60 101
102 Toll House Cookie Pie Prospector Pies -- Wenatchee, WA 87 101
103 Dutch Apple Pie Prospector Pies -- Wenatchee, WA 84 101
104 Pralines N Cream Ice Cream Baskin Robins -- Ellensburg, WA 74 101
105 Chocolate Mint Ice Cream Baskin Robins -- Ellensburg, WA 74 101
106 Cherries Galore Possibility Orchards -- Cashmere, WA 76 102
107 Sour Cream Lemon Pie Cyrus O'Leary's -- Spokane, WA 80 103
108 Sizzling Skillet Apple Pie Cyrus O'Leary's -- Spokane, WA 79 103
109 Boysenberry Pie Cyrus O'Leary's -- Spokane, WA 78 103
110 Huckleberry Pie Bojangles Diner -- Kalispell, MT 85 104
111 Huckleberry Milkshake The Huckleberry Patch -- Hungry Horse, MT 70 105
112 Brownie Pitchfork Fondue -- Medora, ND 60 106
113 Sour Cream Raisin Pie Cowboy Cafe -- Medora, ND 86 108
114 Peach Pie Cowboy Cafe -- Medora, ND 85 108
115 Peppermint Bon Bon Ice Cream Marquis des Mores -- Medora, ND 70 108
116 Apple Pie Cowboy Cafe -- Hulett, WY 80 109
117 Fortune Cookies Chinatown Cafe -- Deadwood Gulch, SD 55 109
118 Walnut Fudge Bars Freedom Grill -- Mount Rushmore, SD 70 110
119 Rhubarb Pie Reetz's Pie Shop -- Custer, SD 86 110
120 Cherry Nut Ice Cream Wall Drug Store -- Wall, SD 65 111
121 Chocolate Nut Fudge Wall Drug Store -- Wall, SD 65 111
122 Maraschino Cherry Whirla-Whip Dakota Drug Store -- Stanley, ND 68 112
123 Butterfinger Whirla-Whip Dakota Drug Store -- Stanley, ND 68 112
124 Peach Pie First Lutheran Church Pie Booth -- Minot, ND 83 113
125 Creme Brulee Pie Pie in the Sky Cafe Booth -- Minot, ND 58 113
126 Cherry Pie Maid-Rite Diner -- Bemidji, MN 83 114
127 Banana Cream Pie Palisade Cafe - Palisade, MN 74 114
128 Strawberry Rhubarb Pie Palisade Cafe - Palisade, MN 79 114
129 5-Layer Raspberry Chocolate Pie Betty's Pies -- Two Harbors, MN 86 114
130 Chocolate Mint Pie Betty's Pies -- Two Harbors, MN 86 114
131 Blueberry Peach Pie Betty's Pies -- Two Harbors, MN 86 114
132 Great Lakes Crunch Pie Betty's Pies -- Two Harbors, MN 84 114
133 Strawberry Pie Betty's Pies -- Two Harbors, MN ** 114
134 Lemon Angel Pie Betty's Pies -- Two Harbors, MN ** 114
135 Apple Pie B's Country Cafe -- Ironwood, MI 68 116
136 Chocolate Pecan Fudge Murdick's Fudge -- St. Ignace, MI 50 116
137 Cherry Chocolate Fudge Fort Fudge Shop -- Mackinaw City, MI 74 117
138 Black Walnut Fudge Fort Fudge Shop -- Mackinaw City, MI 74 117
139 Raspberry Pie Connie's Cafe -- Ossineke, MI 77 117
140 Peach Pie Zehnder's -- Frankenmuth, MI 89 117
141 Blueberry Strudel Zehnder's -- Frankenmuth, MI 84 117
142 Cherry Strudel Zehnder's -- Frankenmuth, MI 80 117
143 Coconut Cream Pie Venus Family Restaurant -- Flint, MI 84 118
144 Almond Tart Jones Bakery -- Jamestown, NY 75 121
145 Coconut Cream Pie Greg'ry's Bakery & Cafe -- Bergen, NY 86 122
146 Pineapple Pie Dick Mazza's General Store -- Malletts Bay, VT 68 123
147 Cookie Dough Ice Cream Ben & Jerry's Factory -- Waterbury, VT 76 123
148 Cherry Garcia Ice Cream Ben & Jerry's Factory -- Waterbury, VT 80 123
149 Blueberry Apple Crisp Pie Cold Hollow Cider Mill -- VT 86 124
150 Apple Pie Cold Hollow Cider Mill -- VT 85 124
151 Moose Droppings Candy Store -- Littleton, NH 70 124
152 Boston Cream Pie Littleton Diner -- Littleton, NH 81 124
153 Banana Cream Pie Gregg's Restaurant -- Pawtucket, RI 88 125
154 Super Chipper Ice Cream Sandwich Newport Creameries -- MA 50 126
155 Cake Donut Bess Eaton -- MA 60 126
156 New York Cheesecake Junior's -- New York, NY 84 127
157 Coconut Custard Pie Athena Diner -- Southport, CT 83 127
158 Salt Water Taffy The Boardwalk -- Atlantic City, NJ 62 128
159 Fire Roasted Rustic Apple Pie Borgata -- Atlantic City, NJ 66 128
160 Peach Pie Bing's Bakery -- Newark, DE 85 129
161 Peach Praline Pie Milburn Orchards -- Elkton, MD 74 129
162 Apple Spice Cake Colonial Williamsburg Bakery -- Williamsburg, VA 79 132
163 Cookie Dough Ice Cream River Country Ice Cream -- North Myrtle Beach, SC 72 133
164 Moon Pie Chevron Gas Station -- Myrtle Beach, SC 70 133
165 Banana Cream Pie Atlanticville Restaurant -- Sullivan's Island, SC 86 133
166 Peach Mountain Pie Bozzie Jane's Kitchen -- Atlanta, GA 83 136
167 Oatmeal Raisin Cookies Bozzie Jane's Kitchen -- Atlanta, GA 80 138
168 Butterscotch Sundae Continental Airlines -- Over the Pacific Ocean 65 142
169 Pua'a Pie Marriott Waikiki Beach -- Honolulu, HI 74 142
170 Mango Smoothie The Habit Cafe -- Honolulu, HI 64 143
171 Hula Pie Duke's Canoe Club -- Honolulu, HI 90 143
172 Chocolate Haupia Pie Ted's Bakery -- Sunset Beach, HI 92 144
173 Peach Bavarian Cream Pie Ted's Bakery -- Sunset Beach, HI 75 144
174 Carrot Cake Ted's Bakery -- Sunset Beach, HI 85 144
175 Macadamia Nut Pie Yum Yum Tree -- Honolulu, HI 85 145
176 Diamondhead Torte Diamondhead Market & Grill -- Waikiki, HI 88 145
177 Banana Pie Diamondhead Market & Grill -- Waikiki, HI 90 145
178 White Sponge Cake The Don Ho Show -- Waikiki, HI 50 146
179 Pineapple Cheese Cake Ted's Bakery -- Sunset Beach, HI 77 146
180 Chantilly Cake Ted's Bakery -- Sunset Beach, HI 70 146
181 Malsadas Leonard's Bakery -- Honolulu, HI 82 147

The Best Pie in America  |  Special Pie Places  |  The Great Pie Adventure  |  Unusual Pies  | 
The Worst Pie in America  |  Methodology  |  Complete List of Pies and Rankings

Trip Overview  |  Cities & States - The Itinerary   |  The Travelers  |  Trip Scorecard  |  Best & Worst  |  Daily Journal  |  The Beads
People We've Met  |  Pie We've Eaten  |  Places Visited  |  Photo Gallery  |  Rules of the Road  |  Road Food  |  Links  |  Our Book  |  Home

www.roundamerica.com * PO Box 681043 * Marietta, GA 30068-0018 * Email: bill@billwindsor.com
Phone: 678-320-0057 * Fax: 678-320-9075 * Toll-Free Phone: 888-736-5633 * Toll-Free Fax: 888-478-1464

© Copyright 2003- 2008, William M. Windsor